← all games

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases

#2511BGG ↗

1981 · 1-8 players · 120min · weight 2.67 · 22,770 ratings

v2 v3

BGG raw

ID
2511
Name
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases
Year
1981
Rank
69
Min players
1
Max players
8
Playing time
120
Min playtime
60
Max playtime
120
Avg weight
2.6652
Num weights
696
Bayes avg
7.36321
Average
7.60364
Users rated
22770
Num owned
44885
Wanting
749
Wishing
8366
Num comments
4297
Fetched at
Sat Apr 25 2026 16:15:26 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Mechanisms (5)
Cooperative GameDeductionNarrative Choice / ParagraphSolo / Solitaire GameStorytelling
Categories (4)
DeductionMurder / MysteryNovel-basedPost-Napoleonic
Description (1426 chars)

Have you ever had the desire to walk the streets of Victorian London with Sherlock Holmes in search of Professor Moriarty? To search the docks for the giant rat of Sumatra? To walk up Baker Street as the fog is rolling in and hear Holmes cry out, "Come, Watson, come! The game is afoot!"? Now you can! You can enter the opium den beneath the Bar of Gold, but beware, that may be Colonel Sebastian Moran lurking around the corner. You can capture the mystery and excitement of Holmes' London in this challenging and informative game. You, the player, will match your deductive abilities against your opponents and the master sleuth himself, Sherlock Holmes. In Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, you are presented with a mystery to solve, and it is then up to you to trace the threads of evidence through the byways and mansions of nineteenth century London. You will interview suspects, search the newspapers for clues, and put together the facts to reach a solution. Why were two lions murdered in Hyde Park? Who is responsible for the missing paintings from the National Gallery? Who murdered Oswald Mason and why? These are just a few of the cases that will challenge your ingenuity and deductive abilities. This is not a board game: No dice, no luck, but a challenge to your mental ability. The game has been thoroughly researched for Holmesian and Victorian accuracy so as to capture a feeling of that bygone era.

LLM v2 (wide)

Core verb
follow lead, read paragraph
Decision shape
combinatorial
Reward schedule
delayed
Aesthetics
["Narrative", "Discovery", "Challenge"]
Core loop pitch
Pick an address or newspaper, read the entry, deduce the chain of clues, then answer Holmes' questions.
Translation difficulty
Easy
Difficulty reason
Pure paragraph-lookup gamebook with a directory and map — Zojoi already shipped Steam case adaptations directly.
Direct digital port
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective (Steam, Zojoi)
Port kind
first_party
Closest loop translation
Return of the Obra Dinn
Primitive tags
["paragraph_branching_lookup", "open_world_clue_graph", "deduction_question_grading", "newspaper_archive_search", "scoring_vs_holmes_par"]
Confidence
0.85
Extracted at
Mon Apr 27 2026 11:40:03 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Raw v2 JSON (958 chars)
{
  "game_id": 2511,
  "name": "Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases",
  "core_verb": "follow lead, read paragraph",
  "decision_shape": "combinatorial",
  "reward_schedule": "delayed",
  "aesthetics": [
    "Narrative",
    "Discovery",
    "Challenge"
  ],
  "core_loop_pitch": "Pick an address or newspaper, read the entry, deduce the chain of clues, then answer Holmes' questions.",
  "mobile_translation_difficulty": "Easy",
  "translation_difficulty_reason": "Pure paragraph-lookup gamebook with a directory and map — Zojoi already shipped Steam case adaptations directly.",
  "direct_digital_port": "Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective (Steam, Zojoi)",
  "closest_loop_translation": "Return of the Obra Dinn",
  "primitive_tags": [
    "paragraph_branching_lookup",
    "open_world_clue_graph",
    "deduction_question_grading",
    "newspaper_archive_search",
    "scoring_vs_holmes_par"
  ],
  "confidence": 0.85
}

LLM v3 (deep)

Not yet enriched at v3 (deep pass).